Lisa's Blog

Wednesday, September 16, 2009

Do my readers influence me?

Today, a reader question from Jordan: How much of what you write is influenced (or could possibly be influenced) by the feedback from critics and/or fans? For example, with relationships: if one character has two possible relationships and you hear a lot of fan feedback in favor of one or the other, could this in any way influence which way you take the story? I promise I have no ulterior motive here, I'm just curious, I promise : )

Since I'm writing these books for you all, you're always in the back of my mind while I'm writing. I try to write what I think you'll like, and about who I think you'll like. That being said, the big plot elements (and yes, I'm talking about the Raine/Mychael/Tam relationship thing) has been worked out for the past two years, and is now hard-wired into my brain, so I don't think I could change that outcome even if I wanted to. I'm trying to make all of you happy, and I think you will be. : )

But I also know you all love reading about Phaelan, Talon, and Piaras. And you like Uncle Ryn and Vegard. So I try to give everyone at least one or two good scenes. It's not easy to fit everyone into a story, but I aim to please. While I'm writing along, I'm very aware of what will annoy you and what would piss you off. And it's pretty much the same things that would annoy or piss me off, so I don't write those things. I don't like reading them in other people's books, so I don't put them in mine. I figure if any of you want to be depressed, you can just turn on the TV or go over to CNN.com.

As to critics/reviewers, if enough of them say the same thing, it just might be worth considering. But for the most part, reviews are the opinion of that one person, and I'm growing a thick skin when it comes to that. Not all people are going to "get it." I've had reviewers have a problem with my using modern speech in a traditional-setting fantasy book. Jeez, that's what makes my books fun to write and to read. I figure that I made up the setting and characters, therefore I make the rules. And since the place came out of my imagination, who are they to say how my characters should speak?

That's something that those of you who are writers can apply to your own work. It's YOUR WORK, not your critique partners, not your writing class members, not even your writing professor's. Only YOU know if it's "right" or not. And in the end, you have to write what YOU want to write, not what other people expect you to write.

Lisa

7 Comments:

Blogger Chicory said...

:) I'm glad we're not overly pressuring you to change the outcome of the relationship tangle. Much as I want things to come out a certain way, I wouldn't want it to happen because you were pressured into out-voting your characters. I think most readers would rather see characters who are true to themselves. That's a LOT more important than having things come out our way. (Besides, if we the readers always got what we thought we wanted, where would the surprises and suspense be?) All that to say thank you for another lovely post.

September 16, 2009 at 8:28 AM  
Blogger Lisa Shearin said...

Thank you, sweetie!

September 16, 2009 at 8:42 AM  
Blogger Nayuleska said...

*nods about the post*

As long as the characters suffer, and have a glimmer of happiness, I'm happy.

Whoever Raine ends up with initially isn't to say she'll be with him permanently. Something might happen...maybe an explosion or a really angry goblin looking for revenge.

September 16, 2009 at 9:56 AM  
Blogger Unknown said...

Usually, I lurk on this blog, but I felt compelled to speak up and say that I've recced your novels to people BECAUSE they use a modern voice in a traditional fantasy world. I find it makes it easier to relate to the characters, and the people I've gotten to read your novels agree. :)

September 16, 2009 at 12:24 PM  
Blogger Lisa Shearin said...

Hi Emily! Don't feel bad about lurking. I read my agent's blog religiously every night (Kirstin Nelson's Pub Rants) and have only commented like 4 times in as many years. ; )

Yep, that's the top reason most people give for loving my books. But as I said, not everyone is going to "get it." So we just have to feel sorry for them that they're missing out on all that fun, and move on. ; )

September 16, 2009 at 12:36 PM  
Blogger Anne said...

So you listen, but only so much? That sounds like a pretty balanced approach. {Smile}

Anne Elizabeth Baldwin

September 16, 2009 at 5:13 PM  
Blogger Lisa said...

I'm so glad you don't have the urge to write those depressing scenes. I too don't care to read sad stories - they get too much in my head.

September 21, 2009 at 4:16 PM  

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home